The Moral Maze of a Festival
We launched this festival in 2020 and since then there has been a lot of learning about what a festival is, what is important to its community, and what is meant by doing the right thing. We've always muddled along, got some things wrong, some right.
This year a couple of threats have come to the fore and required us to speak up. Hopefully this blog explains where we are coming from. The threats are from AI and Sports-washing, but let's start with what a festival actually is...
What is a festival to us?
We think it's a community coming together to celebrate the achievements of its constituents. Usually that's in-person and in one place at one time of year. In our world Banff and Kendal are the leaders. Usually at its heart there is some craftwork. A beer festival is about the craft of making beer. A music festival is music. We are film, specifically documentary, and specifically in the context of adventure. On top of that craft we also celebrate some of the people and organisations that inspire us to explore our passion for adventure further. These are mostly athletes.
We are happy to admit that when we started out our vision was for something that looked more like Banff or Kendal - one event in one place with lots of sponsors and people buying tickets for things. We didn't get there because of Covid, maybe we would have failed for other reasons anyway, but ultimately that path led us here - to a festival that is not in one place but distributed to lots of places, albeit at the same time. It just sort of happened. We liked the fact that it was greener to do it that way, and we liked the fact that it empowered communities.
Why is AI a threat to festivals?
If AI is a threat to art or craft then it's a threat to a festival built on art or craft. This article by the International Documentary Association from a year ago sums it up well. If we are complicit with AI then we are also complicit with AI regimes - including those which are devastating the natural environment. AI is an existential threat to the documentary genre because it offers an alternative to our traditional notion of creativity, of artistry, of craftwork. And what is it doing to audiences? Unable to trust what we see, avoid slop, being fed content designed to open our wallets and not our eyes.
Here you will find a Facebook post from Scouting in Europe that announces their commitment to not using AI to create posters. At first glance this may seem like a silly thing - posters are not art are they? Why not save time making posters and get outdoors instead? But their argument is they exist to connect people with the natural world, not to disconnect them from it. We share that with them.
We didn't get it straight away though, full disclosure. We have previously dabbled in using AI to write text and generate images. You may even find some remnants of those days on this website or our socials. But what we ultimately felt was a loss of joy in what we were doing. So we stopped. Currently our approach is threefold - we don't use generative AI ourselves, we don't platform films that have use AI as a creative tool, and we don't post AI images on social media. Even these commitments are difficult to be 100% sure about, and that is the issue with this insidious technology.
Why is sports-washing a threat to festivals?
This issue has come up because another adventure festival brought a sponsor on board which was widely regarded as manufacturing and selling products that excessively contribute to the use of fossil fuels. It was a decision by that festival organiser, it seemed, to break from a longer-term strategy, and its usual message. They cut a deal which was presumably deemed necessary or acceptable in the short term or on some tactical level. It didn't help that the sponsor was participating at the event in a way that seemed inconsistent with the glorious outdoors. We wouldn't speak out against them, they do loads of good stuff, and only they know the full story.
But the ensung fallout did prompt us to sign a declaration that was circulating from the Cool Down network which campaigns agains sports-washing. We were asked for a quote and this is what we said:
“We signed the declaration because we want our community to know that any sponsors we work with will come from within our community and share their values, the most commonly held of which is that of protecting our world and wild places. We also want to be a passionate festival and not a commercial trade show, so the content has to be as authentic as possible and from within, not without, that community. Sports-washing would feel like a betrayal, but it would also be an unnecessary risk to our project.”
So, we don't just think it's bad for the planet, we think it's bad for festivals. We want festivals to remain spaces where communities can flourish, share and come together to celebrate their best achievements when they bubble to the surface. A good and appropriate adventure festival sponsor in our mind is one who primarily provides to our core, and is therefore a legitimate part of the community, not one for whom we are simply one of many available markets to be exploited.
Navigating the Moral Maze of a Festival
In our careers we have worked on lots of different event types and there are always decisions to be made around morality and ethics. Running a festival is on another level to other events in this regard because you are not just serving a community you are representing it. We will continue to do our best, but mistakes will happen. Everyone makes them. And when you point them out we will fix it. That's a promise.






